Coins are put into a piggy bank
May 31, 2021Rent increase letter: These reasons apply to the rent increase
InvestReal estate rental

Reasons for a rent increase by the landlord

What is a reason for a rent increase and what do landlords need to bear in mind? There are often questions about the permissibility of a rent increase. As a landlord, you must first and foremost observe the legal requirements. Legal regulations on rent increases are set out in Section 558 of the German Civil Code (BGB). It is advisable to always pay close attention to these, as even small errors in the rent increase letter can mean that the planned rent increase is not permissible and therefore invalid. It is possible to increase the rent if it is based on a graduated or index-linked rent according to the rental agreement. Permissible reasons therefore include an adjustment to the local rent index, an expert report assessing the value of the property and modernization or renovation measures. In addition, printouts from a tenant database provide permissible reasons for a rent increase.

Coins are put into a piggy bank

Rent increase after modernization

The rent increase as a modernization levy is a special case. As a landlord, you are allowed to charge your tenant up to 11% of the costs of the relevant measures each year. However, these must be listed in detail in the rent increase letter so that the tenant can understand which renovation and modernization work was carried out and why. It should be noted that there are differences between modernization and maintenance. The latter is the contractual obligation of every landlord and is not a permissible reason for increasing the rent. Which activities count as modernization is set out in Section 555b of the German Civil Code (BGB); according to this, energy-related renovations or work that improves the residential value are considered modernization that also provides the tenant with an advantage.

Rent increase by index-linked and graduated rent

Tenancy agreements can be specified more specifically by means of graduated and index-linked rents. These two variants are less common, but offer some advantages for the landlord. The index-linked rent is based on the cost of living of a private household. It takes into account electricity, gas and water consumption costs, as well as expenses for food and clothing. The amount is based on the consumer price index, which is calculated by the Federal Statistical Office. If the cost of living rises according to this index, landlords can increase the net rent in the same proportion. In the case of graduated rent, the rent is increased by a certain amount at fixed intervals. Both must be stipulated in the rental agreement. In contrast to the index-linked rent increase, the increase does not have to be announced in writing in advance; instead, it takes effect automatically at the defined time. However, a period of at least twelve months must be observed between two rent increases.

Coins are put into a piggy bank

Rental prices according to local comparative rent

If the contract does not provide for an index-linked or graduated rent, it is possible to increase the rent in line with the local rent. The rent index of the city or town must be consulted. It contains information on the local comparative rent. If no rent index is available, you can also send an inquiry to the local authority. An important factor in this type of rent increase is the rent cap or rent brake. Legislation stipulates a maximum rent increase per year or over a period of several years, which may not be exceeded. A rent increase despite the rent cap is generally not permitted. The rent cap mainly affects metropolitan areas, where it is often stipulated that a rent increase for new tenancies cannot exceed 10 percent of the local comparative rent.

Sample letter for the rent increase

A correct sample letter is the essential basis for a permissible rent increase. It must contain a correct salutation, a subject line that clearly states what it is about and a reference to the landlord’s compliance with the rent cap. This means that at least one year must elapse between two rent increases. Other components of the letter include the current rent index, reasons for the increase, a reasonable deadline for the tenant until the rent increase comes into effect and a request for consent. It is best if you directly enclose a declaration of consent for a mutually agreed rent increase. The period for consent must be at least two months. In the course of a rent increase, the tenant has a special right of termination, which they can exercise within two months and which allows the tenancy to be terminated with effect from the month after next.

The comparative rent for a city or town is based on the rent index. If this is not available, comparative rents can also be obtained from the local authority. It is also possible to consult comparative rents in the neighboring municipality.

In the case of modernization measures, a rent increase must be announced at least 3 months in advance. This must be done in writing by letter, e-mail or fax. A period of 2 months must be allowed for approval.

Permissible reasons for increasing the rent are modernization measures, an increase based on a graduated or index-linked rent or as a result of an adjustment to the local rent index. A rent increase in the event of a change of ownership is generally possible, provided the last increase was at least one year ago. The same applies to a rent increase after a new tenant has moved in. If a corresponding agreement has been made in the rental contract, an adjustment due to increased operating costs is also possible.

In addition to the deadlines, it is important to ensure that the rent increase letter is detailed and legally valid. Rectification due to missing content is not permitted; instead, a new attempt to increase the rent should be made. Information on the rent increase includes a justification, the amount, the start date, a right of objection and termination as well as the tenant’s written confirmation.

If a landlord does not accept the rent increase, this may be followed by court proceedings in which the comprehensibility of the rent increase is examined. If the landlord is awarded the right to increase the rent, the tenant bears the costs of the proceedings. These often exceed the rent increase, which is why it makes sense to point this out to the tenant before taking legal action. If the tenant refuses the increase without giving reasons and does not exercise their special right of termination, you as the landlord can file an action for approval. You have three months to do so. The tenant can then be ordered to agree. If he still refuses, he is obliged to give notice.